2/02/2009
Bush Hatred and Obama Euphoria
Read More...
[Source: RETROGRESSING
Report: Most Citizens Kept in Dark on Govt Spending
by Jim Lobe
The vast majority of the world's governments effectively deny citizens basic information they need to understand how public monies are being spent, according to a new report [.pdf] released Sunday by the International Budget Partnership (IBP), a Washington-based project that works with civil society groups to promote government transparency and improve accountability.
Of the 85 countries surveyed by the IBP, only five governments provided what the study called "extensive" information about their budgets, while another dozen made "significant" information available to their publics.
Best performers – those with scores over 81 on a 100-point scale – included Britain, South Africa, France, New Zealand, and the United States, in descending order.
But 68 of the countries – or 80 percent – do not provide the public with comprehensive, timely, and useful information that citizens need to understand and monitor the use of public funds, according to the "Open Budget Index" designed by IBP to measure budget transparency.
And nearly half of the countries provided so little information publicly as to make it virtually impossible to uncover waste, gross mismanagement, or corruption.
The worst performers – those scoring zero or one on the scale – include Sao Tome e Principe, Equatorial Guinea, the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Sudan, Rwanda, Saudi Arabia, and Algeria, according to the index.
"[O]verall, the state of budget transparency around the world is deplorable," the 55-page report found. "In most of the countries surveyed the public does not have access to the comprehensive and timely information needed to participate meaningfully in the budget process and to hold government to account."
"This lack of transparency encourages inappropriate, wasteful, and corrupt spending and – because it shuts the public out of decision making – reduces the legitimacy and impact of anti-poverty initiatives," among other government programs, according to the report, entitled "Open Budgets. Transform Lives."
The survey found that more developed countries tended to offer a higher degree of transparency in their budgetary practices than less developed countries, although there were significant exceptions.
Not only did South Africa rank second among all countries surveyed, but Brazil took eighth place, just behind Norway and Sweden. Peru, Sri Lanka, Botswana, Colombia, Papua New Guinea, and India were also ranked among the top 20.
"The high, good, and poor performers include low-, medium-, and high-income countries," said Warren Krafchik, the IBP director. "In other words, being poor or being dependent on aid or oil and gas revenues is not a sufficient excuse to fail to provide adequate budget transparency."
The survey also found that many poor countries that currently provide insufficient information to their publics are capable of doing so at little or no cost because they already produce that information for their aid donors or for internal purposes.
"All these countries have to do is put the information they already have available on the Internet," he told IPS. "The problem is not really the production of information or the capacity to produce it. The problem is the political willingness by the governments to disseminate that information to their publics."
Indeed, he said, many countries have already taken steps to improve their performance, compared to two years ago when the IBP produced its first survey. Among them were Croatia and Bulgaria, whose accession to membership in the European Union (EU) required them to increase transparency; Sri Lanka and Kenya, where new governments proved responsive to demands reforms by civil society groups; and Egypt, where a new constitutional amendment boosted the budgetary powers of parliament.
"Whether the parliament will be able to use those powers effectively or not remains to be seen," Krafchik said about the constitutional change in Egypt, whose government has long been regarded as both corrupt and authoritarian.
The survey is based on a detailed questionnaire of more than 120 questions focused on the contents and timeliness of eight key budget documents that all governments should issue, according to generally accepted good-practice criteria developed by multilateral organizations, such as the World Bank. The documents cover the government's initial budget proposal through the final audit report when the monies included in the budget have been spent. The survey was limited to the budgets of national governments and did not include sub-national units.
The questionnaires were completed by independent researchers in each of the countries surveyed, and their answers were subject to peer review to ensure their accuracy. Each answer was then given a score, and the combined scores determined the final rankings. As the questionnaires were submitted at the end of September 2007, the survey does not cover governments' performance since then.
The worst performers were mostly located in the Middle East and North Africa, followed by sub-Saharan Africa. In the Middle East and North Africa, the best performer was Jordan with a score of 52, more than twice the regional average of 24. The average of sub-Saharan Africa was 25, despite the strong performance of South Africa (87) and Botswana (62). The average score for all 85 countries was 39.
The worst performers also tended to be low-income countries and often heavily dependent on revenues from foreign aid or oil and gas exports. Altogether, 21 oil- and gas-producing countries were surveyed. Their average score was 23, despite relatively strong showings by Colombia, Norway, and Mexico. Of the 13 worst performers, nine – Sao Tome, Equatorial Guinea, Sudan, Saudi Arabia, Algeria, Angola, Cameroon, Bolivia, and Chad – are oil or gas producers.
By contrast, the 34 countries in the survey that are heavily dependent on mineral wealth, such as gold, platinum, and silver, averaged a score of 44.
The survey also found a correlation between transparency and democratic systems, with all of the 17 countries that provided either extensive or significant budget information assessed as either "full" or "flawed" democracies by the Economist Intelligence Unit's Index of Democracies. Most of the worst performers, on the other hand, were classified as "hybrid" or "authoritarian" regimes.
The report called for governments not only to publish more information about their budgets, but to also produce "Citizens Budgets" that would be easily understandable to the public. Seventeen governments, including Angola, Ghana, India, and Uganda, currently produce them, although they vary considerably in how much information they provide.
The report also urged donor agencies to do more to encourage governments to inform their citizens both by increasing the transparency of their own aid and avoiding funding that is not included in the recipient's budget.
"Wherever possible, aid should flow through country budgets," said Krafchik, who added that this would not act as leverage for increased transparency, but also ease the burden on governments themselves that receive aid from multiple sources and must account to each of them. "This would reduce the incredible strain on the monitoring and reporting capacities of the recipient governments," he said.
Donors should also increase technical assistance for civil society, legislatures, and audit institutions to improve accountability and oversight, the report said.
Read More...
2/01/2009
The Stimulus Shopping List: $1.17 Trillion in Pork Goodies
The Stimulus Shopping List: $1.17 Trillion in Pork Goodies
Having trouble putting down that cigarette? The stimulus bill has $75 million for programs to help people quit smoking. Only 42 percent of Americans now think the bill is a good idea, accordin...
Read More...
[Source: Ron Paul forum
1/22/2009
Tobbaco Users (and others against unfair burden and regulation)... Take note
A friend of mine got a "roll your own" machine recently, because it's dramatically cheaper than buying packs of cigarettes. They are easy to use, and you can control what goes into your cigarette (getting tobacco with no additives or organic tobacco, e...
Read More...
[Source: Ron Paul forum
H.R. 612, To amend section 1922A of title 38, United States Code, to increase the amount of supplemental insurance available for totally disabled veterans
H.R. 612 would amend section 1922A of title 38, United States Code, to increase the amount of supplemental insurance available for totally disabled veterans….Vote on This Bill: For | Against
Read More...
[Source: vote tags: Tracking the Vote
H.R. 600, To revise the requirements for seller-financed downpayments for mortgages for single-family housing insured by the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development under title II of the National Housing Act
H.R. 600 would revise the requirements for seller-financed downpayments for mortgages for single-family housing insured by the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development under title II of the National Housing Act….Vote on This Bill: For | Against
Read More...
[Source: vote tags: Tracking the Vote
The Militarization Of Law Enforcement Continues: See the latest toys
Read More...
[Source: War On You
1/16/2009
Why War?
Excerpt: One of my morning rituals is to have a latte at the Java Shack and spend some time solving all of the world's problems with a crew of regular friends.
Read More...
[Source: AntiWar.com
Martial Law In California
Read More...
[Source: War On You
1/13/2009
Kissinger Again Shills Obama and the New World Order
Read More...
[Source: War On You
1/07/2009
Kissinger: Obamas Opportunity To Form A New World Order
Read More...
[Source: RETROGRESSING
You are being lied to about pirates
Read More...
[Source: War On You
12/19/2008
Blagojevich Says He Has No Plans to Resign
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2008/12/19/blagojevich-pardons-people/
Blagojevich Pardons 22 People
The Democratic governor rarely acted on pardon applications during his six years in office, until now.
FOXNews.com
Friday, December 19, 2008
SP...
Read More...
[Source: WAR ON YOU FORUMS
12/15/2008
US DOT Report Confirms Speed Not Major Accident Cause
Read More...
[Source: War On You
12/13/2008
Father of the Amero Herbert Grubel speaks about a common North American currency
Read More...
[Source: War On You
10/05/2008
You're Going To Guarantee A Depression!!! Ron Paul
Folks, if you have children whose future you care about, you'd damn sure better write Ron Paul in on the ballot this November. Otherwise, it will be the same stauts quo agenda of tearing America down.
http://waronyou.com/forums/index.php?topic=1161.n...
Read More...
Senate Passes Nuke Deal Over Escalation Fears
Excerpt: While the US Senate's approval of a controversial nuclear deal with India was hailed by the White House Thursday as a major advance in Washington's "strategic relationship" with the South Asian giant, weapons experts warned that it dealt a serious blow to more than 30 years of US and international nonproliferation efforts.
Read More...
Bailing Out Wall Street by Selling out Main Street
Read More...
Video: Palin? Well...
In Politics, If You Have to Be Honest, Wait Until the End of Your Term
Excerpt: In politics, truth telling can be dangerous. Remember when Jimmy Carter was voted out of office, in part, for telling the American people, in a time of high inflation and unemployment, what they didn't want to hear -- that they were self indulgent and consumed too much?
Read More...